Should you’re out there for automotive insurance coverage and you reside in Backyard State, you’ve received loads of choices to select from. However figuring out the most effective automotive insurance coverage firm in New Jersey can really feel like making an attempt to place collectively a jigsaw puzzle at midnight. That’s why we’ve put the items collectively for you.
FinanceGrabber analyzed 24 insurance coverage corporations in New Jersey that will help you discover the most suitable choice. We cut up our high picks into 4 classes:
Should you’d relatively see the complete record of the most effective automotive insurance coverage corporations in NJ, together with their star scores, soar to the bottom of the page.
How we discovered the most effective automotive insurance coverage in New Jersey.
Why you may belief FinanceGrabber.
Greatest automotive insurance coverage in New Jersey total: NJM
Headquartered in West Trenton, New Jersey, NJM holds the best total star score out of the 24 corporations in New Jersey we analyzed. As a result of our auto insurance coverage star scores reward corporations for customer-first options and practices, this class represents an total stable selection for New Jersey drivers in search of a well-rounded insurance coverage firm.

NJM
5.0
NJM is amongst our greatest automotive insurance coverage corporations for 2023, however it’s obtainable in solely 5 states.
Reductions
Nice set of reductions
Ease of use
Common
NAIC complaints
Far fewer than anticipated

NJM
5.0
NJM is amongst our greatest automotive insurance coverage corporations for 2023, however it’s obtainable in solely 5 states.
Reductions
Nice set of reductions
Ease of use
Common
NAIC complaints
Far fewer than anticipated
Greatest automotive insurance coverage in New Jersey in your price range: Geico
Geico comes out on high as the most effective automotive insurance coverage in NJ in your pockets. The corporate’s common fee for full protection automotive insurance coverage is $123 a month in New Jersey. That’s the most cost effective automotive insurance coverage fee amongst our record of top-rated insurers. Geico additionally presents a bunch of automotive insurance coverage reductions drivers might qualify for. The corporate can be the biggest insurer in New Jersey.
Nonetheless, your personal fee might be completely different. For a extra complete record of inexpensive choices, take a look at FinanceGrabber’s evaluation of low-cost automotive insurance coverage in New Jersey, which incorporates absolutely the least expensive corporations.

Geico
4.5
With nationwide availability and a raft of reductions, Geico is a well-liked, and infrequently inexpensive, selection for automotive insurance coverage.
Reductions
Nice set of reductions
Ease of use
Common
NAIC complaints
Near anticipated

Geico
4.5
With nationwide availability and a raft of reductions, Geico is a well-liked, and infrequently inexpensive, selection for automotive insurance coverage.
Reductions
Nice set of reductions
Ease of use
Common
NAIC complaints
Near anticipated
Greatest automotive insurance coverage in New Jersey for buyer satisfaction: The Hanover
The Hanover tops our record for the most effective automotive insurance coverage firm in New Jersey for buyer satisfaction. Whereas it’s smaller than different insurers on this record, The Hanover obtained the fewest buyer complaints. Customers should work with an impartial agent to get a quote or purchase an auto coverage.
greatest for buyer satisfaction

Hanover
4.5
The Hanover sells extremely customizable insurance policies in 20 states.
Reductions
Nice set of reductions
Ease of use
Under common
NAIC complaints
Far fewer than anticipated
greatest for buyer satisfaction

Hanover
4.5
The Hanover sells extremely customizable insurance policies in 20 states.
Reductions
Nice set of reductions
Ease of use
Under common
NAIC complaints
Far fewer than anticipated
Greatest automotive insurance coverage in New Jersey for ease of use: State Farm
State Farm is the most effective automotive insurance coverage firm in NJ for ease of use. Prospects can navigate its easy-to-use web site to view coverage particulars and pay premiums. State Farm additionally presents a highly-rated cell app the place customers can entry ID playing cards, file a declare, join with an agent and extra. Tech-savvy clients may even entry their coverage data and carry out different duties by means of an Amazon Alexa gadget.
State Farm
5.0
State Farm presents quite a few reductions and extras together with journey expense protection, making it a good selection for many drivers.
Reductions
Common set of reductions
Ease of use
Above common
NAIC complaints
Fewer than anticipated
State Farm
5.0
State Farm presents quite a few reductions and extras together with journey expense protection, making it a good selection for many drivers.
Reductions
Common set of reductions
Ease of use
Above common
NAIC complaints
Fewer than anticipated
Full record of the most effective automotive insurance coverage in New Jersey
Should you’re searching for much more choices, FinanceGrabber analyzed 24 automotive insurers to seek out the most effective automotive insurance coverage corporations in New Jersey. Listed below are the insurers that earned a FinanceGrabber star score of 4.5 or greater.
5.0 FinanceGrabber score FinanceGrabber’s scores are decided by our editorial workforce. The scoring system incorporates reductions, web site transparency, monetary power, criticism knowledge and extra. |
|
5.0 FinanceGrabber score FinanceGrabber’s scores are decided by our editorial workforce. The scoring system incorporates reductions, web site transparency, monetary power, criticism knowledge and extra. |
|
5.0 FinanceGrabber score FinanceGrabber’s scores are decided by our editorial workforce. The scoring system incorporates reductions, web site transparency, monetary power, criticism knowledge and extra. |
|
5.0 FinanceGrabber score FinanceGrabber’s scores are decided by our editorial workforce. The scoring system incorporates reductions, web site transparency, monetary power, criticism knowledge and extra. |
|
5.0 FinanceGrabber score FinanceGrabber’s scores are decided by our editorial workforce. The scoring system incorporates reductions, web site transparency, monetary power, criticism knowledge and extra. |
|
4.5 FinanceGrabber score FinanceGrabber’s scores are decided by our editorial workforce. The scoring system incorporates reductions, web site transparency, monetary power, criticism knowledge and extra. |
|
4.5 FinanceGrabber score FinanceGrabber’s scores are decided by our editorial workforce. The scoring system incorporates reductions, web site transparency, monetary power, criticism knowledge and extra. |
|
4.5 FinanceGrabber score FinanceGrabber’s scores are decided by our editorial workforce. The scoring system incorporates reductions, web site transparency, monetary power, criticism knowledge and extra. |
|
4.5 FinanceGrabber score FinanceGrabber’s scores are decided by our editorial workforce. The scoring system incorporates reductions, web site transparency, monetary power, criticism knowledge and extra. |
|
4.5 FinanceGrabber score FinanceGrabber’s scores are decided by our editorial workforce. The scoring system incorporates reductions, web site transparency, monetary power, criticism knowledge and extra. |
|
4.5 FinanceGrabber score FinanceGrabber’s scores are decided by our editorial workforce. The scoring system incorporates reductions, web site transparency, monetary power, criticism knowledge and extra. |
|
4.5 FinanceGrabber score FinanceGrabber’s scores are decided by our editorial workforce. The scoring system incorporates reductions, web site transparency, monetary power, criticism knowledge and extra. |
|
4.5 FinanceGrabber score FinanceGrabber’s scores are decided by our editorial workforce. The scoring system incorporates reductions, web site transparency, monetary power, criticism knowledge and extra. |
|
4.5 FinanceGrabber score FinanceGrabber’s scores are decided by our editorial workforce. The scoring system incorporates reductions, web site transparency, monetary power, criticism knowledge and extra. |
|
*USAA is simply obtainable to army, veterans and their households. |